docweasel.com
still an outlaw in their eyes

site menu

docweasel.com
blog
comics
games
monty python
contact
politics

TNR finally bails on Beauchamp, and rightblogs bash the Army

by docweasel Sep 30 2007

via AOSHQ and Jules Crittenden TNR has at long last admitted the Beauchamping of its series of war diaries, in a long-winded, self-serving, blame-avoiding, reckless charge hurling piece with a much obfuscation and distortion as its original Storm Troopers correspondent used to throw around.

All this is unsurprising. Who in the world would expect Foer and Co. to gracefully admit they are unprofessional hacks who lied and stone-walled when faced with the truth that their soldier-reporter was, in fact, a fiction writer, not a journalist.

Foer spends a great deal of time in his rationalization posing as an explanation lashing out at the right-blogs for having the temerity and bad manners to continue to question the article. He conveniently avoids the fact that none of this would have come out had some tenacious freelance investigators not rooted out the truth of the matter.

Others have written on this extensively. What I keep coming across is the scorn and blame heaped on the Army over its role. Of all the entities involved in this fiasco, I fail to see how the Army is at fault.

Here’s an example from QandO Blog: TNR Pulls the Eject Handle

In one sense, TNR is correct. The Army, once again, did its usual stellar job of incompetently handling relations with the press in general, and TNR in particular. Whatever the truth may have been, the Army utterly failed in handling this whole matter transparently, and providing a clear explanation of the methods and results of the investigation. But, that’s been SOP for the Army PIO for the last 40 years.

Dolts.

According to Instapundit, the author at QandO has 40 years experience with military public affairs and information.

Well, I certainly don’t have your experience in dealing with the Army, or the military. In fact, I don’t have any at all.

However, I don’t see where its incumbent on the Army to “handle” the press at all in this type of situation. They are hamstrung by privacy laws in releasing a lot of pertinent info that could help “communicate”. Therefore, its impossible for them to really give a complete picture of these cases and be “transparent”.

Personally, I think its in the Army’s best interest, and their only real duty, to investigate public claims of malfeasance and misconduct by their own soldiers, as in the Beauchamp case.

After investigating, when the case is concluded, they either close the investigation as unproven or false, or they find the subject culpable and mete out appropriate disciplinary actions, as they apparently did.

Why is it the Army’s duty to help clear up TNR’s mess or publicly refute or confirm a soldier’s stories?

I think the Army did exactly what the Army is supposed to do: investigated wrong-doing by one of its own, got his statement in writing, meted out proper discipline, finding his actions severe enough to merit discipline but not egregious enough to merit discharge, gave him the option to leave or stay.

He elected to stay, and according to Michael Yon, at least, whom I happen to trust implicitly, Beauchamp is at least attempting to do his duty to the best of his ability.

He will not have completely atoned for slandering his comrades, no matter how good a job soldiering he does from here on out, until he recants his lies about them and the Army in general, insinuating that the abuses he described are pervasive and tacitly allowed by authorities.

Really, I continue to read how the ARMY screwed this up. I do not think its the Army’s duty to vet every story coming out about Iraq and then explain the entire investigative process to the world.

Their duty is to keep their soldiers doing their job in a moral, legal and effective way. As much as all of us here in blogland would love to know all the teensy details of the investigation (mostly so we can continue to bash TNR and gloat how right we were) its hardly in the Army’s best interest to expend resources to do so.

You know, we don’t even know the real providence of the “leaks”, we assume it was the Army. We don’t know for a fact. They may have been from Beauchamp himself.

I think the Army acted completely correct in this manner. The important thing was to investigate crimes or unbecoming conduct of its soldiers, it did so, it meted out punishment, decided the fate of the perpetrator, and moved on.

Its not the Army’s job to tie up all the lose ends for us. In a great deal of this case, its not even legal for them to do so.

I find zero on which to blame the Army in this case. I think most of the vitriol and blame thrown at them now is because we all want more story, and the Army is not bending over backwards, or even forwards, to give it to us.

Its not their job to do so, and I certainly don’t expect them to do so, even if it would be ’good public relations’ and ’engender good will’.

All that said, chalk up another scalp for the righty blogs: Dan Rather, Mapes, Eason Jordon, Reuters Fauxtography, TNR, have I missed any big ones?

All the leftwingnuts have is Jeff Gannon.

more from:

Jawa Report: The New Republic Sort of Retracts the Scott Thomas Bullcrap Stories

QandO Blog: TNR Pulls the Eject Handle

Michelle Malkin: Bombshell…TNR ‘fesses up: The Beauchamp stories are bullcrap

Dan Riehl: notes Foer’s snitty ad hominem on Matt Sanchez.

Ed Driscoll.com: The New Republic Folds Its Cards

The American Pundit: TNR: We Can’t Stand by Beauchamp’s Stories

Right Voices: TNR Offers A Half-assed We can no longer stand by Beauchamp’s stories

KyleSmithOnline: The New Republic Issues Retraction

Blue Crab Boulevard: Fourteen Pages And Run For Cover

Wake up America: The New Republic Finally Admits They Cannot Stand By The Scott Thomas Beauchamp Fairy Tales

American Digest: New Republic Editor Twists Slowly in His Own Wind

Peenie Wallie: The New Republic Comes Clean

small dead animals: The Baghdad Fictionalist, Updated

BitsBlog: TNR gives in

UrbanGrounds: TNR Lied — But No Dogs Died. Nor Did Anybody Mock a Disfigured Lady

Captain’s Quarters: TNR’s Iraq And A Hard Place

This ain’t Hell: Final chapter of the Scott Thomas Beauchamp saga

Right Wing Nut House: TNR Finally Surrenders

Borderpundit: Beauchamp’s Fictions and The New Republic’s New Fictions

Powerline: Fog of Foer

PJMedia: The New Republic Tries to Come Clean on Beauchamp Scandal

Hot Air: TNR: We can no longer stand by Beauchamp’s stories

Protein Wisdom: Frankly FUBAR

Patterico: The New Republic Retracts Beauchamp Stories

Confederate Yankee: TNR Folds

  • Previous Beckels exemplifies democrat self-delusion16 years ago
  • Next Eject Eject Eject is a great blog16 years ago

site

docweasel.com
blog
comics
sitemap
contact

categories

art
articles
docweasel
gaming
media

games

games
doom & doom][
stronghold
gaming

monty python

monty python
mpfc albums
mp movies
mpfc tv series
2023 docweasel.com. contact us with comments, complaints or suggestions email docweasel.com | join the discussion or bitch and rant at will at DWF forum

categories

blog
art
photos
articles
eros
fiction
humor
opinion
politics
dw website
gaming
movies
movie interviews
movie mini-reviews
movie reviews
movie news
music
chords & tabs
live reviews
metal
music news
music reviews
music video
teevee

recent posts

Nov 24 2013

The Beauty of the Orient is apparent under the moon

Oct 27 2005

Freedom’s just another word for being a fucking talentless hack

Sep 11 2007

"Death of a President" is lefty snuff pr0n

Dec 25 2008

docweasel.com Christmas Gift of the Magi

monthly archive